We're working on allowing customers with multiple policies to use the same email address, but for now, you will need to use a new email address for each policy. Sorry about that.
If you don't already have another email address, if you're with Gmail, there's a pretty simple option.
With Gmail, you can create an 'email alias' that allows you to create a slightly different email address while still receiving emails to your original inbox. When you put your email into our quote site, just pop a '+' after the first part of your email and before the @ symbol. You can then type anything you like.
For example, if your original email was firstname.lastname@example.org, you could change it to the following: